Tax & wealth · Tax residence
Can you be considered a tax resident of two countries?
The short answer
Yes, a person can be considered resident in two countries under their respective domestic laws. Tax treaties then resolve the conflict. In the France–Mauritius convention, the following are applied in turn: permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode, nationality, and finally agreement between the two administrations.
In detail
Why you can be resident in two States
Each State sets its own tax residence criteria. Mauritius, under section 73 of the Income Tax Act, uses domicile (unless permanently resident abroad), 183 days of presence in the year, or 270 days over the year and the two preceding ones. France, according to this site's guide to the convention, does not count days: a home or main place of stay in France, a main professional activity carried on in France or the centre of economic interests in France is enough. A single criterion is enough on each side.
An owner who keeps their house in France, maintains their activities there and spends 200 days a year in Mauritius can therefore be resident in both countries under their laws. This is a theoretical example, but the situation is common among new arrivals.
What the convention calls a resident
Article 4 of the France–Mauritius convention of 11 December 1980 (consolidated version with the amending protocol of 23 June 2011) defines a resident of a State as any person liable to tax there by reason of domicile, residence, place of management or a similar criterion. It excludes persons who are taxed in that State only on income from sources in that State or on capital situated there.
The tie-breaker rule, in order
When an individual is resident in both States, Article 4, paragraph 2, decides by successive criteria; one moves to the next only if the previous one does not allow a conclusion:
- permanent home: the person is resident of the State where they have one available;
- centre of vital interests, if they have a permanent home in both States: the State with which their personal and economic ties are closest;
- habitual abode, if the centre of vital interests cannot be determined or if they have a permanent home in neither State;
- nationality, if they have a habitual abode in both States or in neither;
- agreement of the competent authorities, if they are a national of both States or of neither.
What this changes in practice
The result of this cascade applies for the purposes of the convention: it determines which State you are resident of for allocating the right to tax. It does not remove the obligation to file in the second country if its law requires it.
Two pitfalls come up repeatedly. First, the Mauritian residence permit does not on its own establish tax residence: the law does not mention it. Second, each convention has its own Article 4: the one described here applies only to France and Mauritius. The consolidated text we read predates any effect of the OECD multilateral convention; its applicable version must be reconfirmed.
How we support you
We do not give tax advice, but we review your life plan with you: where you will live, how long you will be on site, what you keep elsewhere. These elements decide the permanent home and the centre of vital interests. Then have your situation validated by a tax adviser.
1 official text cited
Official sources
- France–Mauritius tax treaty of 11 December 1980, consolidated version (amendment of 23 June 2011) — text in FrenchFrench Directorate General of Public Finances (DGFiP)
