Tax & wealth · Tax residence
How is tax residence determined in a conflict between two countries?
The short answer
When two countries both consider you resident, the tax treaty between them applies criteria in a set order. In the France–Mauritius convention: permanent home, then centre of vital interests, then habitual abode, then nationality. If these criteria do not settle the matter, the two administrations decide by mutual agreement.
In detail
The principle: a cascade of five criteria
Where an individual is resident in both States under their domestic laws, Article 4, paragraph 2, of the France–Mauritius convention of 11 December 1980 (consolidated version with the amending protocol of 23 June 2011) settles their situation in stages. One moves to the next stage only if the previous one does not allow a conclusion.
Stage 1: permanent home
The person is considered resident of the State where they have a permanent home available. If they have one in both States, move to stage 2.
Stage 2: centre of vital interests
The person is resident of the State with which their personal and economic ties are closest. The examination takes into account family, activity, assets and income. If this centre cannot be determined, or if they have a permanent home in neither State, move to stage 3.
Stages 3 to 5: abode, nationality, agreement
- Stage 3: the person is resident of the State where they have a habitual abode.
- Stage 4: if they have a habitual abode in both States or in neither, they are resident of the State of which they are a national.
- Stage 5: if they are a national of both States or of neither, the competent authorities of the two States settle the matter by mutual agreement.
If you consider you are wrongly taxed: the mutual agreement procedure
Article 26 provides a remedy separate from domestic remedies. A person who considers that the actions of one State, or of both, result or will result for them in taxation not in accordance with the convention may present their case to the competent authority of the State of which they are resident. The case must be presented within three years of the first notification of the action giving rise to it.
If the objection appears justified and the authority cannot settle it itself, it endeavours to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the authority of the other State, with a view to avoiding taxation not in accordance with the convention.
What to remember
- These criteria apply to France and Mauritius. Each convention has its own Article 4, whose order may differ: do not transpose them to another country.
- The residence permit does not appear among the criteria of Mauritian residence law.
- The OECD multilateral convention (MLI) may have modified certain clauses: the version applicable to your year must be reconfirmed.
How we support you
The first two criteria rest on facts: where you live and where your ties are. Before any purchase, we listen to your plan (living, investing, letting, settling) so that the home chosen in Mauritius and your calendar of presence match your real situation. Choosing the criterion applicable to your case is a matter for a tax adviser.
1 official text cited
Official sources
- France–Mauritius tax treaty of 11 December 1980, consolidated version (amendment of 23 June 2011) — text in FrenchFrench Directorate General of Public Finances (DGFiP)
